Studying tensions between imaginary spaces and concrete places: the method of paired biographies applied to scientists’ laboratory lives

"Spannungen zwischen imaginativen Räumen und konkreten Orten: Die Methode der ‚gepaarten Biographie‘, angewandt auf das Leben von Wissenschaftlern in Laboren". Spaces and places are at the center of the science studies scholarship. Some scholars focus on the spatial circulation of written traces; others focus on the socio-cultural hierarchies reflected in the spatial organization of the laboratories. But most privilege single-case studies as their research method. While single-case studies offer the advantage of providing rich and detailed ethnographic description of spaces, they often fail to explain how imaginary spaces of science are turned into concrete social settings, often with unexpected deviations from their creators’ initial purposes. This paper argues that a comparative approach, which I call “paired biographies,” can help us study the tensions between imaginary and real spaces of science. This method of paired biographies is applied here to trace the attempts (both failed and successful) by two prominent physicists (J.R. Oppenheimer and E.O. Lawrence) to turn their imaginary scientific spaces into concrete places. This comparative approach, based upon paired biographies of various laboratory lives taken at different points in time, highlights the tensions between imaginary spaces of science and concrete architectural forms (themselves located in broader environments), and shows which unexpected outcomes derive from these tensions.


Publication year:
2014
In:
In: Historical Social Research 39, no 2(2014), p 115-136

Note: The status of this file is: restricted


 Record created 2016-06-01, last modified 2019-07-30

Fulltext:
Download fulltext
PDF

Rate this document:

Rate this document:
1
2
3
 
(Not yet reviewed)